13 Modest Halloween Costumes For Teen Girls

This post has some great Modest Halloween Costumes For Teen Girls. Halloween is the perfect time to let your creativity shine, but sometimes finding a costume that’s both fun and modest can be a challenge. Whether you’re looking for something spooky, cute, or classic, there’s a modest costume for everyone. In this blog post, we’ll share 13 adorable and modest Halloween costume ideas for teen girls that are sure to make a statement without sacrificing your values.

This site contains affiliate links, view the disclosure for more information.

Mean Girls Burn Book

This DIY burnbook costume is perfect for Mean Girls lovers. It’s super easy to make! All you need is a pink T-shirt dress and the letters of “Burn Book” printed out and pasted onto the dress! This is perfect to add to your list of Modest Halloween Costumes.

source

White Rabbit

Dressing up as the White Rabbit could easily fit into an Alice in Wonderland group costume, or be super cute on its own. You’ll need a red blazer, a white dress, rabbit ears, a blue bow tie, and a clock purse to pull it all together!

source

Strawberry

This strawberry costume is so fun, easy, and modest! You’ll need a red dress (with DIY seeds) and a leaf headpiece!

source

Belly From The Summer I Turned Pretty

To get in the spirit for the release of season 3 in the summer of 2025, why not dress up as Belly from The Summer I Turned Pretty? I think any of Belly’s outfits would be so cute to recreate but this one is especially fun and easy! All you need is an orange turtle neck and some groovy bottoms!

source

Pheobe Bridgers Skeleton

The versatility of this costume can’t be beat! By dressing up in a skeleton costume you’re paying homage to one of the rising names in indie pop; Pheobe Bridgers! I love this costume because to non-fans you’re just a spooky skeleton, but to fans, you’re the main character of the ‘Punisher’ album cover.

source

Elphaba And Glinda

With the new Wicked movie coming out in November, this is a great costume option for this Halloween season. For Elphaba, you’ll need a witch hat, a black dress, green tights, and green gloves. For Glinda you’ll need a pink dress, pink gloves, shimmery tights, a tiara, and a wand! This is one of the cutest Modest Halloween Costumes!

source

Beetlejuice Lydia Deetz

With the recent “Beetlejuice Beetlejuice” movie release, now is a perfect time to dress up as Lydia Deetz (in her iconic wedding outfit) this Halloween!

source

Dorothy

This would be perfect for a Wizard of Oz or Wicked group costume, or even on its own! To dress up as Dorothy, you’ll need a blue gingham dress, a white blouse, and red gemstone heels!

source

Princess Diaries

I love this iconic Mia look from the Princess Diaries for Halloween! All you need is a white dress, tiara, retro glasses, gloves, and headphones to recreate this look!

source

Chappell Roan

Chappell Roan is rapidly gaining popularity in 2024, so this is a perfect Halloween costume! This can be made super modest with your dress choice. Just make sure your dress is a bright blue color and pair it with gloves, a tiara, a bouquet, and a ‘Chappell’ sash!

source

Coraline

Coraline is an especially spooky Halloween costume idea, that happens to be modest! There are a lot of elements that you could change about this get-up but you’ll definitely need a yellow raincoat and blue wig!

source

The Shining Twins

This is another perfectly bone-chilling Halloween costume! For you and a friend to dress up as The Shining Twins, you’ll need blue doll dresses, knee-high socks, and black Mary Jane shoes.

source

T-Bo From ICarly

T-Bo is a 2000s icon! This is a super cute and modest Halloween costume that anyone would look great in! All you need is an oversized orange polo, a purple bandana, and a stick of bagels.

source

I hope this post helped you find some modest Halloween costume ideas for teenage girls! Whether you’re looking for something spooky, cute, or creative, there’s a costume out there that’s perfect for you. Remember, the most important thing is to have fun and feel confident in your outfit. Happy Halloween!